OK, this is going to be a loooong prologue. I absolutely adore Gautam Menon, period. He is the only film maker apart from Mani Ratnam & Shankar whose movies I cannot afford to miss. I have seen every single movie of his numerable times. Harris Jayaraj's music is bliss to me and I don't miss any of his albums either. Their movies were equivalent to Vamsi-Illayaraja, Mani Ratnam/Shankar - A.R. Rahman combination always MAGIC. I am throughly disappointed that the pair has broken their professional association and I am one of the many people who are praying that they get back together. There are 2 reasons why I am curious about this movie, Simbu pairs up with Gautam & Rehman composes music for Vinnaithandi Varuvaya(VTV). I saw the movie twice in 2 days. I will post a different review for Ye Maaya Chesave because it is a remake and not a dubbed movie and also I have read somewhere that the climax is different for both movies.
Film: Vinnaithandi Varuvaaya
Cast: Silambarasan, Trisha Krishnan, Bob Anthony, Uma Padmanabhan, Samantha Ruth Prabhu & Others
Music: A.R. Rahman
Producer: Madan, Ganesh
Director: Gautam Menon
Release Date: February 26th, 2010
My Rating: 4/5
What's It About:
Boy Karthik(Simbu) meets girl Jessie(Trisha) and its love at first sight. Simple? Not really. Karthik, a mechanical engineering graduate, who wants to become a director is 22, Jessie is a MCA graduate who is 23. That is not the only problem. Karthik is Hindu, Jessie is a Malayali Christian from Kerala. See the problem? Karthik is undeterred by all this and follows her, confessing that he is crazy about her and loves her.Jessie doesn't respond, goes on her annual vacation to beautiful Alappuzha. Karthik follows her to apologize for his foolishness and they decide to be friends.Their decisions do not hold on a train journey where love blossoms. Jessie keeps denying her love for Karthik and their parents know about this. Like any filmy parents Jessie's marriage is fixed but she jilts the guy at the altar. Then comes the interval. Will Jessie & Karthik unite? Will their parents agree? What happens to Karthik's movie career? All these questions are answered in the climax.
Artist Performance:
Frankly speaking I am not a big fan of Simbu. I think he is the epitome of mass Dialogues and cinematic over-action. His pairing with a classy director Menon was shocking and to his credit Simbu is perfect as the underplaying Karthik. He is likeable as a lover boy and he excels in the romantic scenes. Trisha, I have never thought of her as a performer. In this movie she is beautiful. The way she acts as a confused girl in love unable to betray her father is perfect. I loved her simple costumes in the movie. Ganesh who acts as Simbu's friend has good screen presence. Bob Anthony is nice as Trisha's father.
This & That:
It is a difficult task for any movie maker to base a film on just 2 charectors and it takes a lot of guts. There is a tremendous scope of boredom especially when there is no comedy, fights etc and the film does not bore you though it has some dull moments. The romantic scenes where Trisha looks over her shoulders in fear of her dad, the train scenes and the scenes after the interval where she confesses her love are so real. I loved Minnale(Cheli) & Vaaranam Aayiram(Surya S/o Krishnan) for the romance and love between the lead charectors and this movie just takes the cake. There is subtle humor infused in the scenes like Karthik humming the tune from Bombay in the church, Mustafa Mustafa background music when they decide to be friends. That brings me to music, A.R.Rahman is mind-blowing. The thing about Rahman's music is you have to listen to the songs over and over to experience the nuances. The background score is Awesome. The use of guitar strumming in the crucial scenes and Aaromale in both the romantic and tragic sequences are brilliant. My favorites are Hosanna, Omana Penne & Aaromale they are on repeat in my car as well as my I pod. Cinematography by Manoj Paramahamsa is ethereal. Majority of the movie is shot in Kerala and it is God's own country, truly breathtaking. I feel like going to Kerala and hopping on a houseboat! That being said, there are also some negative points which could have been avoided. The whole Nandini track is unnecessary, scenes after the interval are slow and screenplay could have been better. The Anbil Avan song before the climax is unwanted and it reminds me of Manjal Veyil song. Choreography is not up-to mark and it reminds me of Vaaranam Aayiram(Surya S/o Krishnan). Climax is shocking but it suits the whole feel of the movie.
Did I Enjoy It?
Yes, It is a real love story which talks about the difference in temperaments of a girl and a boy in love. Go Watch It NOW!
P.S. I have happened to know that YMC is a scene to scene copy of the movie, so I will do some edits to this post when I see the movie and not post a new review.
So I watched Ye Maaya Chesaave. I just wanted to add a few points to the post.
Naga Chaitanya has improved considerably since his last movie. He still has to improve a lot in diction and dances. But he seems to have a promising career. Samantha is nice. A very restrained performance. I dunno why people are going gaga over her? Guess that is a man's perspective. Dialogues are a copy of the Tamil one's but nevertheless fresh. Climax is nice. Gautam Menon said that he had guts to shoot an alternative climax for the Tamil version & not the Telugu One. I liked the Tamil Version just because it seemed more real taking into account the whole premise of the movie. This just shows me that we have a long way to go in terms of cinematic growth. All in all, an enjoyable watch!